Property Insurance Claims

Frequently Asked Questions

Straight answers about first-party property insurance claims — what to do after a loss, what your policy means, and what to do when your insurer denies, delays, or underpays.

1.What is a first-party property insurance claim?

A first-party property insurance claim is a claim you make directly with your own insurance company after your home, business, or other insured property suffers damage. Common examples include claims for hurricane damage, wind damage, roof damage, fire damage, water damage, theft, or other covered losses.

2.What should I do immediately after my property is damaged?

Start by making sure everyone is safe. Then document the damage with photos and videos before making permanent repairs. If temporary repairs are needed to prevent further damage, such as tarping a roof or boarding a window, save all receipts. You should also report the claim to your insurance company as soon as possible and keep a written record of every communication.

3.Why is documentation so important in a property insurance claim?

Insurance companies rely heavily on evidence when evaluating a claim. Photos, videos, receipts, repair estimates, inspection reports, and a written communication log can help prove the extent of the damage and the value of your loss. The more organized your documentation is, the harder it may be for the insurer to undervalue or dispute your claim.

4.Should I take photos and videos before hurricane season?

Yes. Pre-loss photos and videos can be extremely helpful if you later need to file a claim. They can show the condition of your home, roof, personal belongings, appliances, improvements, and valuables before the storm. Store copies digitally so you can access them even if you evacuate or lose access to your property.

5.What should I include in a home inventory?

A home inventory should include valuable personal property, furniture, electronics, appliances, jewelry, art, tools, and other belongings. Include purchase dates, receipts, serial numbers, appraisals, and photos when possible. A spreadsheet, home inventory app, or cloud folder can make this easier to update and preserve.

6.What insurance policy terms should homeowners understand?

Important policy terms include deductible, hurricane deductible, replacement cost, actual cash value, exclusions, endorsements, loss of use, additional living expenses, named perils, and open perils. Understanding these terms before a loss can help you know what is covered, what is excluded, and what out-of-pocket costs may apply.

7.What is a deductible?

A deductible is the amount you are responsible for paying before your insurance coverage applies. Some policies have a flat-dollar deductible, while others have percentage-based deductibles for certain losses. Hurricane and wind deductibles can be higher than standard deductibles, so homeowners should review them before storm season.

8.What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?

Replacement cost coverage generally pays the cost to repair or replace damaged property using today’s prices, without subtracting for depreciation. Actual cash value, often called ACV, subtracts depreciation based on age, condition, and wear and tear. This difference can significantly affect the amount paid on a claim.

9.What are policy exclusions?

Exclusions are situations, causes of loss, or types of damage that are not covered by your policy. Common exclusions may include flood damage, earth movement, sewer backup, wear and tear, neglect, or pre-existing damage. Some excluded risks may be covered through separate policies or endorsements, depending on your situation.

10.Does homeowners insurance cover flood damage?

Standard homeowners insurance policies typically do not cover flood damage. Flood coverage usually requires a separate flood insurance policy. Gulf Coast property owners should review their flood risk and coverage options before hurricane season, especially if they live in low-lying or storm-prone areas.

11.What is an endorsement or rider?

An endorsement, sometimes called a rider, is an add-on that changes or expands your insurance coverage. Examples may include water backup coverage, scheduled personal property coverage, equipment breakdown coverage, or ordinance and law coverage. Endorsements can help fill gaps in a standard homeowners policy.

12.What is loss of use or additional living expenses coverage?

Loss of use, also known as additional living expenses or ALE, may help pay for temporary housing, meals, and other necessary expenses if your home becomes uninhabitable after a covered loss. This coverage can be important when repairs or rebuilding take weeks or months.

13.How can I prepare my house for hurricane season?

You can prepare by documenting your property, reviewing your insurance coverage, trimming trees, securing outdoor furniture, inspecting your roof, sealing openings where water could enter, installing shutters or impact-resistant windows, reinforcing garage doors, and preparing an emergency plan. You should also keep important documents, including your insurance policy, in a safe digital location.

14.What should I do if I evacuate before a storm?

Take important documents with you, including identification, your insurance policy, your home inventory, and emergency contact information. Keep receipts for hotels, meals, gas, and other necessary expenses. Depending on your policy and the facts of the loss, some expenses may be reimbursable under loss of use or additional living expenses coverage.

15.Should I make repairs before the insurance company inspects the damage?

You should take reasonable steps to prevent further damage, such as tarping a roof or drying out water intrusion, but you should document the damage first. Avoid making major permanent repairs before the insurance company has had an opportunity to inspect, unless emergency conditions require immediate action. Always save receipts and keep records of any work performed.

16.What should I do if my property insurance claim is denied?

Carefully review the denial letter and compare it to your policy. Look at the specific reason the insurer gave for denying the claim, the policy language it relied on, and whether the facts support that decision. Then gather additional evidence, respond promptly to requests for information, document all communications, and consider getting professional help if you believe the denial is wrong.

17.Does a denied insurance claim mean the case is over?

No. A denial is not always the final word. Some claims are denied because of missing information, policy misinterpretation, incomplete inspections, or disputes over the cause of damage. Depending on the facts, a denied claim may be challenged through additional documentation, negotiation, appraisal, mediation, litigation, or other available procedures.

18.What are signs that my insurance company may be underpaying my claim?

Warning signs may include an estimate that is far below contractor pricing, missing damage from the insurer’s scope, refusal to account for code upgrades, unexplained depreciation, or payment that does not cover necessary repairs. If the insurer’s estimate does not match the real cost to restore your property, you may need to challenge the valuation.

19.What is insurance bad faith?

Bad faith may occur when an insurance company fails to handle a claim honestly, fairly, or reasonably. Examples can include unreasonable delays, unjustified denials, failure to properly investigate, misrepresentation of policy terms, refusal to communicate, or lowball settlement offers without a proper basis.

20.What are common red flags of bad faith claim handling?

Common red flags include unexplained delays, repeated requests for the same documents, conflicting statements from insurer representatives, refusal to provide written explanations, ignoring communications, denying a claim without a clear policy basis, or relying on an incomplete investigation to underpay or deny the claim.

21.When should I get a lawyer involved in my property insurance claim?

You should consider speaking with a property insurance lawyer if your claim is denied, delayed, underpaid, or disputed. Legal help may also be important if the insurance company accuses you of fraud or misrepresentation, the damage is extensive, the policy language is unclear, or you believe the insurer is acting in bad faith.

22.What does a property insurance attorney do for policyholders?

A property insurance attorney can review the policy, evaluate the insurer’s coverage position, gather evidence, work with experts, communicate with the insurance company, challenge delays or denials, negotiate for a fair resolution, and file a lawsuit if necessary. The attorney’s role is to help level the playing field between the policyholder and the insurance company.

23.Will hiring a lawyer automatically mean filing a lawsuit?

No. Many property insurance disputes are resolved without trial. A lawyer may be able to help through policy review, evidence gathering, negotiation, mediation, appraisal, or other dispute resolution methods. A lawsuit may become necessary if the insurer refuses to fairly resolve the claim.

24.How does a first-party property insurance lawsuit work?

A first-party property lawsuit usually begins with investigation and evaluation. If a lawsuit is filed, the complaint explains the loss, the policy, the insurer’s conduct, and the relief being requested. The insurer then responds, and both sides exchange evidence through discovery. Many cases resolve through settlement or mediation, but some proceed to trial.

25.What should I bring to a consultation with a property insurance lawyer?

Bring your insurance policy, denial or payment letters, photos and videos of the damage, repair estimates, inspection reports, receipts, claim number, correspondence with the insurer, and any notes from phone calls or adjuster visits. The more information you provide, the easier it is to evaluate your claim and identify the next steps.

The information provided in this FAQ is for general informational purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice. Every insurance claim is different, and the outcome of any claim depends on the specific facts, policy language, deadlines, and applicable law. If you have questions about a denied, delayed, or underpaid property insurance claim, contact Averill & Reaney to discuss your situation.

Still have questions about your claim?

A denied or underpaid claim isn’t always the final word. Talk to us at no cost.